Easy Sweet Potato Casserole
Comin’ atcha, with a brand new Easy Sweet Potato Casserole recipe with orange and pecans that is totally comforting and classic tasting, but so easy to make entirely from scratch. Don’t worry it doesn’t have any marshmallows, just delicious candied pecans, brown sugar, cinnamon and butter on top to make these ultra-creamy sweets irresistible on your Thanksgiving plate! And the best part is, it can be made a day ahead so it’s one less thing to worry about on Thanksgiving.
Table of contents
Why We Love This Easy Sweet Potato Casserole with Pecans and Orange
If you’re hosting Thanksgiving this year, don’t let the pressure get to you; I got your back, friend! Not only do I have your whole Thanksgiving Planner ready at your fingertips, but I have a tried-and-tested Roasted Turkey you’ll use year after year.
And now I have this brand new Easy Sweet Potato Casserole made with a crunchy sweet pecan topping instead of marshmallows!
As the name implies, this Easy Sweet Potato Casserole is really easy to prepare. It can also be made ahead of time! If you have time the day before Thanksgiving, I recommend adding this to your prep list. It will make the day of Thanksgiving so much smoother. And you’ll be so much calmer knowing that your sides are ready to pop in the oven when your (gorgeous, juicy, brined) turkey comes out.
Serve this sweet potato casserole on your Thanksgiving table along with dishes like Green Bean Casserole, Gluten-free Cornbread, Sausage and Cranberry Stuffing and more. There is sure to be something for everyone to enjoy!
Ingredients for this Recipe
Of course, this dish would be nothing without the main ingredient sweet potatoes! Steam the sweet potatoes until they are soft and tender to make this sweet potato casserole irresistibly soft and delicious.
Orange Juice and Zest
I love the combination of orange with sweet potato, so I used both orange zest plus orange juice. It adds so much flavor you’ll never want sweet potatoes without orange again. Full stop.
Cinnamon and Nutmeg
There is no such thing as Thanksgiving without cinnamon and nutmeg and I make it my personal mission to add it to as many dishes as possible. I used a full two teaspoons of Cinnamon in the mashed sweet potatoes because they really soak up a lot of flavor and I added in some of Nutmeg, but in a much smaller amount, because it can be a bossy spice that can take over. Additionally, I found that ¼ teaspoon in the mashed sweets was plenty.
Butter and Brown Sugar
Since I was going for a traditional classic sweet potato casserole recipe, I went for it and added melted butter and brown sugar. This is the holidays after all. It makes these sweet potatoes creamier and sweeter, which means that they’ll be a total crowd-pleaser. Plus the flavors will pop against the other savory recipes like the Roasted Garlic Mashed Potatoes or the Gluten-free Quinoa Stuffing.
Note: If you prefer an unrefined sweetener, you can use granulated maple sugar.
Fall calls for pecans! Top this casserole with pecans to add a delicious nutty flavor along with some crunch to the casserole.
Step By Step Instructions For This Easy Sweet Potato Casserole
This is the best sweet potato casserole recipe ever. It is easy to follow, can be prepped in just 20 minutes and tastes absolutely amazing. Seriously, this dish is definitely Thanksgiving side dish goals and it is sure to have everyone coming back for more!
Prepare Sweet Potatoes
- First start off by prepping the sweet potatoes. Peel them entirely, and cut off the fibrous tips. Then cut them into 2-inch chunks.
- Next steam the sweet potatoes until they are very tender. This takes about 20 minutes. You can test to see if they are done by pressing your fork into the sweet potato and if the fork slides in and then out easily you know they are completely soft. That will give you the creamiest result.
Mash The Sweet Potatoes By Hand Or In A Food Processor
- You can mash the sweet potatoes by hand with a potato masher, or you can puree them in a food processor. I actually prefer the ultra smooth texture when they’re pureed. But if you like a more rustic texture, you can mash them up by-hand in a minute flat.
- You’ll want to add the orange juice mixture as you mash.
- Note: my food processor is large so I was able to puree the entire batch of sweet potatoes (about 7 cups) in one go. However, if you have a smaller food processor, you’ll have to do it in two batches. Try your best to divide the orange juice mixture between the batches, and then stir them together well at the end.
Top the Sweet Potato Casserole with a Mixture of Pecans, Brown Sugar and Butter
Instead of topping this sweet potato casserole with sad and predictable marshmallows which could hardly qualify for worthy of “the Best Thing in Life” status this Sweet Potato Casserole has a super easy pecan topping made with brown sugar and butter and a hit of The Spice Hunter cinnamon and nutmeg. That alone will have your Thanksgiving guests weak in the knees as they smell it baking! I promise!
- Chop Pecans: To make the topping, simply chop ¾ cup of raw unsalted pecans. (I like to buy them in bulk and then store them in my freezer. They keep longer that way.)
- Add Butter and Brown Sugar: Then toss the pecans with a little melted butter, brown sugar (or you could use granulated maple sugar), Spice Hunter nutmeg and cinnamon.
- Add The Topping: Top the mashed sweet potatoes mixture with the topping.
- Bake Until Nuts Are Candied and Toasted: Let the topping candy in the oven. I tested this sweet potato casserole a lot of times and I can say with assurance that you want to let it bake long enough for the topping to really toast and candy. Something special happens. When you see the pecans start to brown, that means it’s ready. The brown sugar and butter mixture will coat the nuts and make them crispy in the best, most magical way possible.
How to Make it Start to Finish on Thanksgiving
If you have to work late on Wednesday or can’t prep it ahead for some other reason, no worries, you can also make this simple sweet potato casserole recipe from start to finish too. Once you add the nut topping, just pop it in the oven. It will bake much faster because it won’t be cold, so it will be ready in about 35 minutes. Again, set a timer and check on it after 30 minutes to make sure the nuts do not brown too much.
FAQs and Expert tips
Sweet potatoes are native to Central and South America while yams are native to Africa. What makes things confusing is that traditional recipes, like candied yams with pecans, are actually made with sweet potatoes. And if you look on the can of store-bought candied yams, in small letters below it will specify that it’s not yams but indeed sweet potatoes.
Sweet Potatoes are higher in sugar and yams are starchier. Yams also have thick woody skin, and sweet potatoes’ skin is relatively thin by comparison. While there are a lot of hefty sweet potatoes at the market these days, some yams are huge (5 ft long!) You can read more about it here.
So here’s what you should know, sweet potato pie and sweet potato casserole are not the same dish. Sweet potato pie is a popular dessert that features a creamy sweet potato filling baked in pie crust. While, sweet potato casserole is a side dish made with sweet potato chunks and is topped with nuts or marshmallows.
To make sweet potato casserole ahead of time, prepare the sweet potato mash, and top it with the nut mixture, then cover it and stick it in the fridge for a day. Then when the turkey comes out, set the oven to 350 degrees, remove the cover from the casserole and bake it until the topping is showing the deliciously telltale signs of being roasty toasty and the brown sugar is turning to a crispy sugary candied coating. This takes about 50 minutes when the casserole goes in the cold. Just keep an eye on it, and when the nuts start to brown, you’ll know it’s ready.
It is vital that sweet potato casserole is baked to perfection. Sweet potato casserole is done once the nut or marshmallow topping has browned and the center of the casserole is set and firm.
Additional Recipes To Try
- Broccoli and Cauliflower Casserole– this one can be made a day ahead too and is a creamy contrast to the other side dishes
- Cranberry Sausage Stuffing with sage, Italian sausage and dried cranberries. This is a classic stuffing recipe I make over and over.
- The pies can be made a day ahead as well. It’s hard to choose one, but I think my favorite is this Maple Cranberry Apple Pie.
- Not everyone makes salad on Thanksgiving, but if you do, this Kale Salad with Delicata Squash is a good make ahead option. Build it and make the Maple Sherry Dressing the day before (if you have room in your fridge that is!)
Thanks so much for reading! If you are new here, you may want to sign up for my email newsletter to get a free weekly menu plan and the latest recipes right to your inbox. If you make this recipe, please come back and leave a star rating and review. I would love to hear what you thought!
Happy Cooking! ~Katie
Easy Sweet Potato Casserole Recipe
- Total Time: 1 hour 10 minutes
- Yield: 12 servings 1x
Sweet Potatoes mashed with Orange Juice, Butter, The Spice Hunter Cinnamon and Nutmeg. Topped with chopped nuts tossed with brown sugar, butter and more cinnamon and nutmeg. Instructions to include how to make ahead and reheat in the oven once the turkey comes out.
4 large sweet potatoes, about 3 ½ pounds
½ cup orange juice
8 tablespoons (1 stick) melted butter, divided
5 tablespoons brown sugar, divided
1 teaspoon orange zest
¾ teaspoon salt
2 ¼ teaspoon cinnamon, divided
½ teaspoons ground nutmeg, divided
¾ cup chopped pecans
- Bring 1 to 2 inches water to a boil in a large saucepan fitted with a steamer basket. Meanwhile, peel sweet potatoes and cut into 2-inch chunks. When water comes to a boil, place the sweet potatoes in the steamer basket, cover saucepan and let steam until the sweet potatoes are fork tender, 20 to 25 minutes. Using an oven mitt, lift the steamer out of the saucepan and slide the sweet potatoes out into a large bowl.
- Add orange juice, 6 tablespoons butter, 3 tablespoons brown sugar, orange zest, salt, 2 teaspoons cinnamon and ¼ teaspoon nutmeg and mash with a potato masher until smooth. Alternatively, puree in a food processor (in two batches) for an ultra-smooth consistency. Transfer the mashed potatoes to a 3 quart casserole dish coated with cooking spray.
- Combine pecans in a small bowl with the remaining 2 tablespoons butter, 2 tablespoons brown sugar and the remaining ¼ teaspoon each cinnamon and nutmeg. Toss to coat. Spread the spiced nut mixture over the sweet potatoes and cover. Refrigerate up to two days. See alternative instructions to bake immediately.
- Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Remove cover and transfer the casserole to the oven and bake until heated through and the nuts are toasted, candied and fragrant, about 50 to 55 minutes. Let cool at least 5 minutes before serving.
Tip: If baking immediately, do not cover with foil. Bake at 350 degrees until hot all the way through and the nuts are toasted, about 30 to 35 minutes.
- Prep Time: 20
- Cook Time: 50 minutes
- Category: Side Dish
- Method: Stove Top and Oven
- Cuisine: American
- Serving Size: 2/3 cup
- Calories: 202
- Sugar: 9 g
- Fat: 15 g
- Saturated Fat: 5 g
- Carbohydrates: 18 g
- Fiber: 2 g
- Protein: 2 g
Keywords: sweet potato casserole,easy sweet potato casserole,sweet potato casserole with pecans,healthy sweet potato casserole,sweet potato casserole with orange
I made this for our neighborhood Friendsgiving. It was the hit of the entire dinner…besides the turkey. I shared this recipe with most of my neighbors and their family members. I’ll definitely put this on my list for next year.
I am worried between mashed potatoes and puréed sweet potatoes that it will be too many mushy textures. Could I slice the sweet potatoes in rounds and then use the butter, spices, and orange juice as a kind of glaze, then Put that delicious pecan toppings on top?
You’re smart to consider textures. I do the same. I am not sure if that will work. My concern is allowing the sweets to get tender enough and making sure they are not unevenly raw. I think if I was to try that I would take the butter, orange and spice and simmer it in a little saucepan. Arrange the potatoes and then drizzle the sauce over. Cover with foil and bake until they are fork tender. Then add on the topping and bake again. Maybe a bit hotter and on the upper rack, just to brown the streusel. I am not sure that will solve your mash problem though because they will end up being soft.
I assume the orange zest is added to the sweet potatoes when you add the OJ.
Yes in step 2. Enjoy!
One of our favorite side dishes to make for the holidays! Really love how you added the orange to this!
Hey Suzy, Thanks so much! Have a great holiday!
Such a great recipe! Definitely serving this at thanksgiving!
Yay! So psyched to hear it! Happy Thanksgiving Laura!
This is really amazing! a great addition to our Thanksgiving menu!
Thanks Toni. So glad you added it to your menu. Hop you loved it as much as we did.
This is really amazing!! A great addition to our Thanksgiving menu!
I am so glad you liked it!
This looks so delicious! I love that I can make this the day before Thanksgiving, it’s going to take some wait off the day of.
Yes! Love recipes like that, that can be made ahead!
This is the ultimate comfort food! I love having healthy options for the holidays!
So glad you like it! Have a great holiday!
i love me some potato casserole! thank you for sharing this recipe 🙂
Thanks Lisa! Have a great Thanksgiving!